glenwearden · Nov 23, 2004 03:03 PM
#0 sourceAm I all wet? Thoughts?
Glen
Glen Wearden
Stuka Stunt Main Forum · 52 of 52 known posts recovered
Glen Wearden
I certainly think that there's a lot to be said for being in direct contact with the plane... feeling the pull on the lines, and seeing the direct result of any control input. I have NOT flown R/C, so I don't have any direct comparison, but I have played some video games, which I'd guess would be about the same feeling. I have to say that the video games don't engage me the way flying my planes does...
Tim
MAAC 65703
Yet, it still comes down to twiddling some sticks like a video game. As a matter of fact, unless you learn to fly close, which many don't do, it's worse.
Tom B
I have been asked by many people including my neighbor, “When are you going to MOVE UP to R/C?” I’ve never had a good answer to that question, only to usually reply something to the effect of “I don’t feel it would be moving up”.
I can’t knock R/C pilots, I’m sure they love their toy planes as much as I love mine.
I met Jeff Welliver from MN this past spring at the Pewaukee WI contest; good guy. I can’t recall verbatim what it was but he had a great answer to that type of question. It was something like “ I’ll fly R/C when I feel like taking it easy and stepping down to some easier flying”.
Hey Jeff, chime in on this one.
Chris
Two answers
1)since RC is older than CL why move back to the older control system.
2)As soon as I get physically unable to fly CL or FF
Have always got a kick out of RC flyers saying that their plane felt better that flight, man they must have LONG fingers.
Thanks for the compliment !
As I recall the wind that day, sliding down a 30'razor blade into a pool of iodine would have qualified as taking it easier.
I'm on here a couple of other times, and on the thread on Control line promotion, all comparing with R/C.
Jeff
On the other hand, the slightest mistake and it's tinder.Sorry if I rambled.
J.R.
Ty,
I built two or three Goldberg 1/2A Blazers. They were lots and lots of fun, but I lost every one of them as a fading pinpoint in the sky. I could never meter the fuel in a Baby Bee, and the de-thermalizer fuse always fell out from the rubber bands.
I finally retrieved one once from Cades Cove in the Smoky Mountains. I jumped a fence, and before I realized it, a bunch of bulls were staring me down, threatening to charge. I slowly backed up and went the long way around to get my plane.
I'm sure every Free Flighter has the tall tale of the one that got away!
Tom B
... no real touch
... HE SAID:
"If I compare {RC} to C/L, it is like sex by phone - no real touch."
*** ONE FOR THE AGES ***
Tom B
Bigiron (68 years of modeling madness and still enjoying it)
Bigiron13
Used to fly FF with Pat Johnston and Jim Welch in Idaho. Much the same as Marvin describes. Nothing but miles and miles of sage brush and a lot of nothing as far as you could see. An area called Freezeout Ridge above Emmett. Not far from Firebird drag strip. Well over a hundred in the summer and insane thermals and not much else. So days it would be the middle of the afternoon and dead calm and hot, hot, hot. Lost many a hand launch glider out there. Just pitch it up and watch it circle out of sight. But Jim flew the killer planes. Wakefields! Loved that Whump, whump, whump when he let it go with an enormous balsa prop and probably too much rubber motor. What a blast.
Besides, it was just too hot to fly CL at a 110, dead calm and 3700 feet. 
Edit: In fact, much like the picture you posted. Must be Eastern Oregon or Idaho. I-80?
With CL, every plane feels different and the nuance of movement is transmitted directly to your nervous system. That direct connection is hard to beat so:
Step up to Control Line.
Gary Weaver
"I don't know about this tuned pipe business. I practiced on that thing until my lips turned blue, and I still can't play a stinkin note."
"Homer J. Simpson"
Milton Graham\Proparc
Jim Kraft
).When the character of a man is not clear to you, look at his friends.
Japanese Proverb
RC boring ? Most RC sunday flyers fly their trainer or sports plane. Try to fly only your CL trainer and i think you get bored to fly level flight very quickly. Many (most?) CL stunt flyers fly in competitions and that is the reason why it is so exiting.
And if you think all RC is boring, go ahead and try RC AirCombat. Never boring and still cheap fun.
Feel ? There is some "feel" on the RC planes also. You notice it when you change your plane and fly with a different plane. Every plane has it's own "feel".
Regs, Jyrki
From somewhere near Parkville, Mo.
William Crane
AMA 6733
If you wish to get excited flip your Heli inverted 1 foot from the ground turn it nose in to you , just remember that your controls are reversed all , and you really can't be thinking which way do i move the sticks, then do a backward loop from nose in and come to a stop 1 foot from the ground still nose in. Yes there might not be this magic feel but guys don't you ever compare RC and C/L when flown by competent people .It makes it look like poetry in motion It's the same comparison as a Ringmaster and a SV 11.Furthermore most flyers that are skilled do not fly way out. That is the mark of a beginmner who is letting the plane fly him. The same as a beginner in any sport, the equipment owns you till you master it.
I have flown every facet of the hobby with the exception of turbines and would never be so snobbish as to allude that one facet of the hobby is better then the other. I enjoy them all.
Dennis
Or Pylon Racers. That was a lot of fun though not at all cheap.
I disagree on feel. The all "feel" the same. The response time and abilities of the plane vary, but they all feel the same at the sticks. Very much a video game feel.
I've been a space flight simulator addict since the days of "Elite" on a C=64, through the Wing Commander Saga and all the way to today flying Starlancer, Freelancer and recently, the new SpaceWars. But until the advent of Force-Feedback joysticks, it was largely a non-responsive system (though still a lot of fun). Your Thrustmaster felt the same whether you were cruising around Los Angeles in a Cessna with Microsoft Flight Simulator or strafing a Kilrathi Battlecruiser while being fried from behind by a Dralthi. It all felt the same even if the "experience" was different.
Maybe that's an idea for RC. A force-feedback system on the sticks. 
I still enjoy flying the park flyer type in my cul de sac, or the local school, but they handle less wind than even a small C/L.
I do love the smell of nito and castor oil!
Bill Heher
If it's broke, fix it.
If it aint broke - let me see it for a minute.
One word: Ebay 
Phil C
Phil, While I have the greatest regard for the pattern champs of the 60's they were flying a completely different pattern then is flown today. it was with fairly small,fast planes and reasonably wide open maneuvers. Not so today the emphasis is on power, turnaround and stay in the box type of flying. I did fly aa lot of those older designs but never went too far into the modern large,YS 110 powered stuff, I'm not one to bury myself in the good old days. They were but they are gone and I'd rather create some newer 'good old days' Incidentally, Don Lowe is not using a plain vanilla radio today. He uses top of the line digital stuff. Another point is that you can't believe how many older modellers are intimidated by computer radios and as a result limit themselves to simplistic trainer type models when really they still want that B-17 with all the bells and whistles. Kind of like some of the barriers that flyers here put up for themselves. heck they are only toy planes and your not in them.Live a little and have fun.
Dennis
Phil C
Rob Duckering....MAAC #14457
www.acfc.ca
The best day like this I ever had was when I even had some of my rockets, when a pack of Cub Scouts showed up in three vans. The councilors were hoping there would be more people flying, but I was able to put on a one-man show with rubbber, rockets, R/c, and finishing up with a Goldberg 1/2A Shoestring. The kids were having a ball pretending to be AA shooting at the plane. Of course, the Piece' de Resistance was coming out of a loop in front of them, my up line broke, at about 5' altitude. The kids were jumping up and down with the exitement of "We got him. We got him."
The councilors tried to apologize and offered payment for the plane, but I just pointed out how excited and happy the kids were, and told them it was worth every minute of the show and the loss of the plane.
Making kids happy.
That's living!
I have flown every fixed wing model except monoline and RC jets. Jets are too expensive for me, may be one day Mono will come. Just a slow model just to say i did it!
All aeromodelling modelling is good modelling.
Fly a model on the side of a hill for 4 hours (RC) and thats flying. But, a good flight with Palmer Chief and that is a buz too.
But then a big RC glider on the end of a 450 ft tow line nearly lifting you off your feet in a thermal is too, a good feeling.
There are too many interesting models to build and no time.
Cheers John Q
John Quigley
Not even damp. All or at least almost all of our local CL retreads are ex RC. They simply say CL is more fun.
Also, IMO, you run into a much better class of modeler in CL. In local RC circles the king of the hill is the guy who spent the most money for his RC ARF and all the bells and whistles that go with it and flying and building skill is a non factor.
Steve Hulse
Tom B
Glen Wearden
The last time I flew R/C was about 25 years ago, with a trainer from a friend. I never did completely lose the confusion with the controls when if was coming towards me, but I'll have a chance again soon. I put a park flyer on my Christmas list.My wife, who has enjoyed flying both control line and FF, thinks it would be neat to fly with the kids in the front yard.
Time will tell, but I don't think I'll really get hooked into R/C. But I will probably end up with a park flyer and a big old old timer FF with R/C so I don't have to go so far to retrieve it...
John
I'm too lazy to re-write it here, but look at my response (#8) on the CONTROL LINE PROMOTION THREAD regarding the differences between flying R/C and C/L.
You're right: we need to get away from this idea that radio is the highest form of modelling. To me PA is the highest of the piloting skills, and top level free Flight is the Purest Science. Before I get lynched over that, REMEMBER, once that guy let's go of that lightweight, overpowered bomb with a screaming nitro burner on the front, ALL he can do is watch and pray. At least we can try to avoid disaster.
Jeff
EDIT; I try not to let it show too often but my real problem is I get sick and tired being asked when I'll "move up" to R/C or seeing even our National leadership (AMA) treat us like second class citizens. I know, we're just a small fraction of the membership and "we should be thankful for what we do get", etc. Yeah, that's the real world but at my age I do reserve the right to occassionally get P.O.'d and even "politically incorrect".
Oh yes, my actual answer when somebody asks why I don't move UP to R/C usually is "when I get too old and senile to fly C/L, I'll move DOWN to R/C".
Jeff