Stuka Stunt Control Line Forum
Archive, 2000–2021 · recovered from the Internet Archive
Forums › Stuka Stunt Main Forum

4 stroke Nobler

Stuka Stunt Main Forum · 9 of 9 known posts recovered

Phil · Jan 18, 2004 04:07 AM

#0 source
Has anyone out there tried an OS 30 Surpass in an ARF Nobler? We've got one in the shop and it looks really nice........

Phil.

This discussion's going round in circles...........!

peabody · Jan 18, 2004 06:21 AM

#1 source
Phil:

I know the Neal Beekman has a Saito .40 in his and is just as happy as if he had sense.

I also know that Z-man has a Saito .30 in his Brodak Nobler and thinks that it is nifty.


See Ya

Peabody

ama65006 · Jan 18, 2004 11:43 AM

#2 source
I have a Saito 30 in my Ringmaster and it flies real nice when all combos are right , better than a Fox 35 in the same plane. I don't think it has enough power for a Nobler as my Saito 40 flies the Nobler real nice. The Saito 40 Mounts are the same as the Fox 35 the difference is in the weight and the shaft is about an inch forward. The Saito 30 Needs a smaller space between motor mounts. After blowing the rod and making junk out of my RS Fox 35 i put the saito 40 in my ARF Nobler, just for fun, any way it flies real nice. See Ya Neal P.S. I never had to shim the tank and it runs the same inverted, even left the same tank as the Fox

Bob Reeves · Jan 18, 2004 01:37 PM

#3 source
I have flown my 500 sq/in Twistmaster with both the Saito 30 and Saito 40a. I feel the 30 would be OK for sport flying but the first contest you attend with the wind over 10 MPH you will be wishing for the 40.

Proparc · Jan 18, 2004 07:20 PM

#4 source
>Has anyone out there tried an OS 30 Surpass in an ARF
>Nobler? We've got one in the shop and it looks really
>nice........

Bob Zambelli is all over the Nobler with the Saito 40a. Saito 40a looks like the minimum for any Nobler.

Phil · Jan 19, 2004 01:48 AM

#5 source
LAST EDITED ON Jan-19-04 AT 02:08 AM (CDT)
 
Thanks for the replies, I'll see if the 40 Surpass is available and compare them. I won't be competing with the Nobler

Phil.

This discussion's going round in circles...........!

Alan Hahn · Jan 19, 2004 11:38 AM

#6 source
LAST EDITED ON Jan-19-04 AT 11:39 AM (CDT)
 
Phil,
FWIW, My Saito 40 weighs 10.8 oz and my OS Surpass 40 weighs 12.5 oz. Both were with their stock mufflers and stock carbs (just weighed them on my digital scale).
So if you don't already have the 40 Surpass, you might consider the weight difference.

Alan

V12 · Jan 19, 2004 01:50 PM

#7 source
Gentlemen: I have used both the (SAITO).30 and .40 in my Brodak Nobler, as pictured. It flys extremely well with either engine but the .40 just gives it a bit more authority and allows longer lines. The weight is around 41 ounces with the .30 and, as I recall, 2 more with the .40 (larger tank, too). I tried a Surpass .26 and it was fine untill the wind kicked in. I have also flown it with a Fox .35.
I would not reccommend the Surpass .40 for the Nobler. It's a brute of an engine and, in my opinion, just too much power. For what it's worth, I have a Surpass .40 in my Euclid and it flys very well at 57 ounces and around 100 more square inches than the Nobler!!!
By the way, two local expert flyers flew the Nobler with the SAITO .40 and said it's the best flying Nobler they ever tried.

Bob Z

V12 · Jan 19, 2004 02:53 PM

#8 source
Like a dummy, I did not read closely enough (long drive back from Florida!). You asked specifically about the ARF Nobler/4S combination. I have not tried it myself but Neal Beekman has and was quite pleased. If you are interested in 4S engines and the many experiences we've had with them, I can put you on my 4S information exchange list. There are about 100 people and a great deal has already been learned. Just write to me at and I will include you.
Bob Zambelli