Stuka Stunt Control Line Forum
Archive, 2000–2021 · recovered from the Internet Archive
Forums › Stuka Stunt Main Forum

My white dope turned yellow!

Stuka Stunt Main Forum · 29 of 29 known posts recovered

Crist Rigotti · Feb 24, 2004 11:30 PM

#0 source
Guys,
What am I doing wrong. I only have had this problem since switching to Brodak. The last 3 airplanes all have had the white turn yellow after I spray on the clear topcoats. Not a happy camper.

Crist Rigotti
"A driver trying to be a pilot."
http://www.clguy.com

LNeumann · Feb 24, 2004 11:35 PM

#1 source
How old is the clear and what does it look like? There was a bad batch of clear a couple of years ago that turned orange. Matt had the problem on one plane and the next year when he got out the clear he noticed it had gotten almost a bright orange (true). John replaced the dope and also did some checking with the factory. I don't know what was the problem but I haven't heard of the problem since. Pour a little clear into a jar and tell me what you see.

Leonard Neumann

Iskandar Taib · Feb 25, 2004 05:31 AM

#3 source
Dang.. Wish I'd known at the time - I'd have offered to buy some of the "orange" dope for a low price. Probably works great if you want an orange airplane.. ^_-

LNeumann · Feb 25, 2004 09:01 AM

#5 source
>Dang.. Wish I'd known at the time - I'd have offered to buy
>some of the "orange" dope for a low price. Probably works
>great if you want an orange airplane.. ^_-

Actually it worked fine for undercoats and filler. Just make sure to put a blocking coat over before going to final colors. The new clear we have had no problems with. I think it was limited to just one batch. And, as always, John will make things good (with the exception in this case of repainting the airplane). Any product can have a flawed run. Just look at how many recalls we have on cars and airplanes (why do car manufacturers have to pay the cost of the recall on cars, but with airplanes it is the owner's responsibility to update before he gets clearance to fly it again?)

As I said, we have had no problems with the new stuff and I certainlyu wouldn't knock the product because of one bad batch.

Leonard Neumann

Bigiron13 · Feb 25, 2004 09:09 AM

#7 source
Some time back, I had some plastizer that turned yellow.
I first noticed that the white dope I was using it in turned a pale yellow after a couple of months. Then, as it got older, the plastized got a sort of rust color to it. I threw it out.

Bigiron

Bigiron13

Bob Reeves · Feb 25, 2004 02:45 AM

#2 source
What is your base/filler? Are you using all Brodak from the wood to clear?

I am on my second all Brodak finish and so far so good.

Crist Rigotti · Feb 25, 2004 07:52 AM

#4 source
All Brodak. I got the clear several years ago. Despite the smell, I'm going back to Sig. At least I got good solid and bright colors.

Crist Rigotti
"A driver trying to be a pilot."
http://www.clguy.com

LNeumann · Feb 25, 2004 09:06 AM

#6 source
>All Brodak. I got the clear several years ago. Despite the
>smell, I'm going back to Sig. At least I got good solid and
>bright colors.

Crist, I am still thinking it was the clear coat and the result of the one bad batch that slipped through. The color change came about after manufacture, so it was something they could not foresee. We had a gallon can of the stuff, and in its first use it was absolutely clear. It yellowed over time on the airplane. The next year, however, when Matt was about to paint his next rendition, the stuff poured out of the can looking orange. Very peculiar and John took this back to the manufacturer for analysis. If that is your problem, talk to John and he will make it good. And don't be afraid of the new stuff. Whatever it was, the problem was solved.

Leonard Neumann

Randy · Feb 25, 2004 12:21 PM

#8 source
LAST EDITED ON Feb-25-04 AT 12:21 PM (CDT)
 
Crist,

Could also be the mix. I had some clear that turned quite yellow. It was Randolph's dope. I put a little too much retarder in (painting on a rainy day - always a bad idea). It looked fine at first but started to yellow within a couple of days.

But Len is probably right. Just a bad batch of dope.

Randy Powell

ty marcucci · Feb 25, 2004 04:10 PM

#9 source
"My white dope turned yellow"; my best blue tick houn died; my boomerang won't come back; my pick up broke down. Hmmm. lots of "blues" tunes here. A little humor there, darn little.

Bill Little · Feb 25, 2004 09:08 PM

#10 source
Well, Ty, you're headin' into a "Country" when you talk about hound dogs, and pick up trucks. Add some beer/liquor, a woman, and a shot gun and you'll have a platinum country hit. Garranteed.
Bill <><

Just an Old Advanced flyer.

cyclone · Feb 25, 2004 09:43 PM

#11 source
You forgot trains, jail, Mama, and rain.

Jim Kraft

Bill Little · Feb 25, 2004 10:10 PM

#12 source
LOL!!!! If you get all that in there, you'll have the biggest country hit of all time.
Thanks, Jim, I needed that!
Bill <><
Just an Old Advanced flyer.

william davis · Feb 25, 2004 11:00 PM

#13 source
Hey Bill,

Throw in a couple of lines about a loaded mule getting blinded.. or something like that ???

Might be a hit

Come to the meeting sat , if the snow melts, I will give you a couple flights on the Imitation, I think you will like it alot..

William

William Davis

Crist Rigotti · Feb 25, 2004 11:09 PM

#14 source
LAST EDITED ON Feb-25-04 AT 11:28 PM (CDT)
 
I've been thinking could the white have turned yellow because I loaded up on the clear. I added extra coats on the high wear areas. This is where it started first and after a few days it was basically the whole plane.

Here's some pics.

On the first picture look along the fillet area to see the yellowing.


Crist Rigotti
"A driver trying to be a pilot."
http://www.clguy.com

Bill Little · Feb 26, 2004 06:56 AM

#15 source
Crist,
It seems that it really was just a bad batch of clear. I have seen certain clear enamels turn "yellow" over time, but not "good" clear dope.
I have seen clear dope put on so heavy that it ran, but it stayed clear.
Any chance there was any contamination in the gun?
Bill <><

Just an Old Advanced flyer.

Crist Rigotti · Feb 26, 2004 07:51 AM

#16 source
No contamination. Everything was kept clean and sealed.

Crist Rigotti
"A driver trying to be a pilot."
http://www.clguy.com

N42222 · Feb 26, 2004 12:56 PM

#17 source
Crist, Is there possibly something working its way through the layers to the surface- like Ambroid glue. It's amber colored. You used all brodak dope- what about adhesives? Just guessing. The auto paint store where I used to go said that the replacement from ChromaClear gives a yellowish hue in time. Best regards,

Crist Rigotti · Feb 26, 2004 01:10 PM

#18 source
LAST EDITED ON Feb-26-04 AT 01:12 PM (CDT)
 
Dale,
Nothing coming up from the bottom. I use Pica Gluit or CA. The bottom view where the LG attaches shows how widespread and severe the problem is. As you can see, I'm in the middle of sanding off my newly finished model just ot do it over again. I'm going back to Sig and if I have no more problems then I'll know for sure what brand to use in the future. Thanks for the ideas,

Crist Rigotti
"A driver trying to be a pilot."
http://www.clguy.com

LNeumann · Feb 26, 2004 03:59 PM

#20 source
Have you poured a little of the clear into a jar just to see if there is any tint there? As I and others have said, there was a bad batch. Nothing since. It is not a problem with Brodak dope as such as it is not a recurring problem. If you contact John I am sure he will replace the clear that you have. Even though we ourselves experienced the same problem, we have and continue to use Brodak dope because the stuff is good. If we quit buying every product that ever had a recall, we would be living in caves today and walking barefoot.

Come to think of it, there was a problem with the server that this forum is being hosted on. And we discovered several bugs in the software. And I had to reload the operating system on my computer. And the e-mail systemn (outside the computer) still isn't working correctly.

Leonard Neumann

Crist Rigotti · Feb 26, 2004 11:16 PM

#21 source
>Have you poured a little of the clear into a jar just to see
>if there is any tint there? As I and others have said,
>there was a bad batch. Nothing since. It is not a problem
>with Brodak dope as such as it is not a recurring problem.
>If you contact John I am sure he will replace the clear that
>you have. Even though we ourselves experienced the same
>problem, we have and continue to use Brodak dope because the
>stuff is good. If we quit buying every product that ever
>had a recall, we would be living in caves today and walking
>barefoot.
>
>Come to think of it, there was a problem with the server
>that this forum is being hosted on. And we discovered
>several bugs in the software. And I had to reload the
>operating system on my computer. And the e-mail systemn
>(outside the computer) still isn't working correctly.

Len,
I did pour some in an epoxy mixing cup along with Sig clear in another. I really couldn't tell the difference between the two. I know what you are saying, but try to remember this has happened to every (4 of them) airplane I used Brodak dope on. That is why I keep thinking I'm doing something wrong. I do like the fact Brodaks is less smelly and it dries quickly. I'm re-considering Brodaks. We'll see and I'll post my results.

Crist Rigotti
"A driver trying to be a pilot."
http://www.clguy.com

LNeumann · Feb 26, 2004 11:21 PM

#22 source
Since you said it happened to every plane you built, did you use the same clear on all of them? What are you using for a base? I am trying to see if anything is bleeding up. Did you add retarder. That can be the biggest culprit in causing "meltdown" where the top layers eat into the bottom layers.

Leonard Neumann

Crist Rigotti · Feb 26, 2004 11:35 PM

#24 source
LAST EDITED ON Feb-27-04 AT 00:10 AM (CDT)
 
>Since you said it happened to every plane you built, did you
>use the same clear on all of them? What are you using for a
>base? I am trying to see if anything is bleeding up. Did
>you add retarder. That can be the biggest culprit in
>causing "meltdown" where the top layers eat into the bottom
>layers.

Len,
Yes all the same dope. I got the clear and thinne in quarts, and the white in pints? No retarder, it still is pretty dry. While I was sanding off the yellow finish, it looked like it was the clear that had turned yellow. Though I'd say some of the white was yellowed too which could have been caused by shooting the last several coats too thin. I never had a run, but came close.

The base was all Broday with 3/10 cf. Nitrate to adhere the cf, several coats, the butyrate filler, several more clear, the 2 platinnum grey, 6 white, then trim collors. 2 dry clear, then 4 wetter and thinner coats with 1/2 between each. I started to notice the yellow by now. Overnight drying, light sanding then 2 thinner and wetter coats. Overnight and a few days later the yellowing became very apparent.

Crist Rigotti
"A driver trying to be a pilot."
http://www.clguy.com

Bill Little · Feb 26, 2004 11:51 PM

#25 source
Crist,
It is a mystery. And, I am sure, quite frustrating. I know that certain finishes, older enamels, etc., are known for yelloowing, but I have just never experienced it with any dope finish. I guess I have been lucky in that regard. But I have had a recurrance of "nuclear melt down" recently because I went to a different thinner. It works great on the colors, but when I use it for the clear coats, it really eats into the colors. Even made my ink lines disappear on one plane!
Good luck,
Bill <><

Just an Old Advanced flyer.

Charlie Chan · Feb 28, 2004 11:27 PM

RE%3A My white dope turned yellow%21#27 source
I have heard of some Lite coat clear covered planes turning a slight yellow (the clear coat).

Seems like quality control has long been a problem in the Hobby industry. (as well as many others)

Charlie Pate

ty marcucci · Feb 26, 2004 01:11 PM

#19 source
LAST EDITED ON Feb-26-04 AT 01:11 PM (CDT)
 
Crist, I have a plane built by Ed Culver covered with Brodaks clear over white and it too turned a light yellow color. The clear, not the white. Sanding on the clear brought the white out. Ed built this plane several years ago and may have used the same batch of clear you did. I was going to just sand the plane down to base color, but decided to strip it down to wood. Bad move, but too late now. Yours is the third case of clear turning yellow I have heard about, and all were from clear purchased a few years ago, nothing since.

C/L Gee Bee · Feb 26, 2004 11:27 PM

#23 source
Mike Lauerman

Guys: I have had the same problems, with the same products; also other brands. I think we should look beyond this, i.e.: 'why do they call it 'clear'?' It's like the Constitution.

SRiese5283 · Feb 27, 2004 02:16 AM

#26 source
I've had to re-do two white planes done with brodaks. However, I think the problem has been fixed.....I hope.

Scott(doing a white plane now)Riese

Scott Riese

David Hoover · Feb 29, 2004 08:22 AM

#28 source
Simple solution - don't use white on your planes and the yellowing clear won't show. Just kidding!

Best, Hoovie

Life is simple. Eat. Sleep. Fly.