Stuka Stunt Control Line Forum
Archive, 2000–2021 · recovered from the Internet Archive
Forums › Stuka Stunt Main Forum

B-Y&O props

Stuka Stunt Main Forum · 25 of 25 known posts recovered

KnightFlite · Jun 07, 2004 07:11 PM

#0 source
Hi everyone, I,m getting ready to stock up on some props and was wondering if these props are worth the extra money, for my fox 35 stunt. I normaly use zinger woods with good results---I think!? Thanks, Paul

De Hill · Jun 07, 2004 07:22 PM

#1 source
You might try an APC 10-5. Having several 10-5's and 10-6's of different manufacturers is a good trim tool for the Fox .35.

LNeumann · Jun 07, 2004 10:14 PM

#2 source
The 10-6 BY&O is an excellent prop for the Fox 35. They are in shnort supply at the moment, however, as Brodak is retooling. Once they get the tooling done, however, then they should be back in abundant supply.

KnightFlite · Jun 07, 2004 10:31 PM

#3 source
Thanks Leonard, i think i will give e,m a try! - Paul

dirtydan · Jun 08, 2004 10:02 PM

#4 source
Paul,

I suggest caution. When you hear many of us referring to use of a B-Y&O 10-6 prop, for example on a Fox 35, we are actually referring to props produced by Clarence Bull. I will sometimes refer to these as Real Deal B-Y&O props.

When Brodak bought Clarence's tooling and they had all up and running, I bought 6 each of 10-5s and 10-6s. A rejection rate of 100%.

Word came in that the tooling had been spiffed up throughly. Waited a suitable amount of time in hopes of supply line being purged of substandard props, specifically asked for new-production pieces, was assured that I was getting good 'uns and new-release 'uns.

Again, all the props were very nearly useless *for my particular application,* that being decently healthy Fox 35 on a nice Oriental.

They may be the coolest thing yet on something like a Thunder Tiger 25 or a Combat Wombat, I would not know.

All that said, I am hoping they figure out how to make the props correctly, although even Clarence hardly had a perfect record in this regard, plus base material is not dimensionally stable.

But I am down to only a few known-to-be-good B-Y&O 10-6s, currently fly from a grass field and with the constant fear of nosing over, snapping a blade I am using APC 10-6s, this made possible by release of Randy's High Zoot crankshaft, fitting of same to my motor courtesy Larry Foster.

Dan

P.S. Big, wet kiss for the first to cite what "Combat Wombat" reference is all about. Dan

LNeumann · Jun 08, 2004 10:10 PM

#5 source
I have not experienced your frustration, Dan. There is a lot of hand work on these props with the old tooling, and that was the biggest downfall when John had a girl doing the work who probably didn't even know what a prop was. She made a run of them with the Philips "entry" in the trailing edge. John did make good on these. But I happen to have an original Clarance Bull copy of the 10-5 and 10-6 here and compared these to the last batch I got from John, and, if the wrapping were taken off and one didn't look at the emblem you would have a hard time telling me which was which.

He is retooling to CNC equipment (as Clarence, himself, considered doing at one time) and this will result in much quicker production with each prop being as identical as wood props can be.

dirtydan · Jun 08, 2004 10:29 PM

#6 source
>I have not experienced your frustration, Dan.

You have been quite lucky. In addition to the props I purchased I have looked at a great many Brodak-produced 10-6s. Not a good one in the house.

>There is a
>lot of hand work on these props with the old tooling, and
>that was the biggest downfall when John had a girl doing the
>work who probably didn't even know what a prop was. She
>made a run of them with the Philips "entry" in the trailing
>edge. John did make good on these.

Of course there was a lot of hand work. Just as there was when this old tooling was brand-new. The Phillips-entry was never carved in with machinery. What is a girl who might not even know a prop from a glow plug doing applying the final touches? Now I'm even more filled with angst over my depleting supply of 10-6s.

But I happen to have an
>original Clarance Bull copy of the 10-5 and 10-6 here and
>compared these to the last batch I got from John, and, if
>the wrapping were taken off and one didn't look at the
>emblem you would have a hard time telling me which was
>which.
>

I will buy some more to see if this is the case. However, Reagan's admonition to "Trust but verify," will be in full force. At this point in time I simply do not believe it. In any case, I have found that actually flying the props is the only way to tell if Brodak, or my good friend Clarence back then, had gotten it right with any individual prop.

>He is retooling to CNC equipment (as Clarence, himself,
>considered doing at one time) and this will result in much
>quicker production with each prop being as identical as wood
>props can be.

Again, I hope so. I need a bunch of real good Y&O 10-6s. I **do not** need any more $5.00 prop kits, already have plenty of those.

Dan

Brett Buck · Jun 08, 2004 10:49 PM

#7 source

>P.S. Big, wet kiss for the first to cite what "Combat
>Wombat" reference is all about.

I know, but I'm not going to say, for reasons that are all too obvious.

Brett

dirtydan · Jun 08, 2004 11:00 PM

#8 source
>
>>P.S. Big, wet kiss for the first to cite what "Combat
>>Wombat" reference is all about.
>
> I know, but I'm not going to say, for reasons that are
>all too obvious.
>
> Brett

Brett,

You were disqualified from the beginning, having been placed on super-secret double probation. And I believe that you do know, although I myself hadn't thought of it for many years, have no idea what caused the words to jump from mind to finger tips.

Dan

Dr Spark · Jun 08, 2004 11:02 PM

#9 source
So I visited Clarence in Harrisburg some years back, and I took some pictures of his operation and wrote a piece for Stunt News (or was that SAM SPEAKS?) Anyway, I recently bought about $300 of the last of the B-Y&O props and distributed them to my friends at cost. Most of them are already gone. The last props that Clarence made were from ash, and not nearly as nice as the earlier ones made from maple. And I have a few really nice props made from curly maple with interesting grain pattern. These nice ones have been distributed to my friends in England, but I keep a couple for myself.

Clarence had a shed in back of his garage that had hundreds of board feet of interesting wood waiting to me made into props. There was birch, ash, maple and other stuff I couldn't identify. I wonder what ever happened to his pile of wood.

Floyd

KnightFlite · Jun 09, 2004 01:11 AM

#10 source
Thanks for all the words of wisdom guys!! Since its no great emergency, I guess I,ll just keep using my remaining zingers and cave in and buy a couple apc props, while John Brodak gets his prop tooling back up to snuff. You see Im not knocking apc props, and keep hearing good things about them, Its just that I have this nostalgia fetish going on for the ole wood props thats way beyond any sort of pscychiatric treatment that modern science can offer! So I learn to live with It. Paul

Jim P · Jun 09, 2004 08:18 AM

#12 source
>cave in and buy a couple apc props, while John Brodak gets his prop tooling back up to snuff. You see Im not knocking apc props, and keep hearing good things about them, Its just that I have this nostalgia fetish going on for the ole wood props

After using the APC 10-5's on a good Fox and suitable airplane there is a good chance you will get over your nostalgia.
They are usually pretty close to being in balance but balance anyway. Sand just a little of the sharpest part of the blades with 220 grit to avoid almost impossible to avoid finger slashes. The less you sand here the better. Complete the balance by lightly sanding the outer portion of the blade flat with 220.

Steve Baker · Jun 09, 2004 03:22 AM

#11 source
>They may be the coolest thing yet on something like a .....
>Combat Wombat

10-6 on a Hodaka? They were rubber powered, weren't they?

James C Johnson · Jun 09, 2004 11:48 AM

#13 source
Here is a picture of the props made by Bill Schagerman in 1979. Stanton Hobbies also produced these props around 1965. The Y&O prop is almost model aviation folk-lore. I personally think the APC props are ugly, and just try to ream one out. Plus fitting them to a spinner is a real education. All in all they are cheap and the LHS never has the ones I need in stock. I was able to buy these props for a buck a piece, all are 11x6. Jim J

dirtydan · Jun 09, 2004 12:23 PM

#14 source
>They may be the coolest thing yet on something like a .....
>Combat Wombat

>>10-6 on a Hodaka? They were rubber powered, weren't they?

And we have a winner! Steve Baker is hereby issued a coupon, redeemable at any NW Stunt contest, and good for a big, wet kiss from Da Dirt.

Entire Hodaka line of motorcycles were powered by rice, not rubber. I am surprised this need be pointed out to you, but my offer remains valid despite this horribly inacurrate statement, albeit one put forth in the form of a question.

Dan

dirtydan · Jun 09, 2004 12:57 PM

#15 source
As to Dr. Spark's response, I have heard that Clarence made early B-Y&O props from maple, but I do not recall actually seeing any of them. A friend has indicated he has a bunch in 10-5 and 10-6 sizes, although they never seem to show up at contests.

By the time I got around to using Clarence's props he was making them in tulip wood, a material I found lacking. We could sometimes hear prop blades flopping around, at least I think that's where the noise was coming from.

Still, even in a more flexible wood than maple, a high percentage of the props worked to "okay" standards. The ash props from Clarence were a big improvement while still being hardly my favorite material when compared to maple.

I wonder, with new Chinese connections, if thought has been given to the B-Y&Os being made in China? Sounds like the obvious thing to do, especially with all the hand work required.

Plus we know the Chinese will have actually trained their workers as to what the end product must look like. And can be counted upon to have actual quality-control stations spread along the line, will most certainly have one in operation immediately before the shipping department.

Dan

Steve Baker · Jun 09, 2004 06:48 PM

#16 source
>And we have a winner! Steve Baker is hereby issued a coupon,
>redeemable at any NW Stunt contest, and good for a big, wet
>kiss from Da Dirt.
>Dan

Arright! I have a couple of brothers living in Edmonds, I'll
time my visit to coincide with a contest.... I get to pick the
spot where that kiss will land, right??

BTW My brother had a Cotton, only saw a couple of those and only
in the NW. Think those were gin powered. Me, I was a little kid,
had a Super Rat..

KnightFlite · Jun 09, 2004 07:26 PM

#17 source
Hodaka!! super rat, durt squirt, combat wombat, and the one I got stuck with, The Steen!! Gee thanks for the memos!! Paul

Steve Helmick · Jun 09, 2004 09:40 PM

#18 source
Dan has derailed yet another thread at SSW.

Believe it or don't, the Master Airscrewed WOOD props are not all that bad. I bought a 10-5 and checked pitch, and it was very close to constant from root to tip...and as advertised, 5". They are available in 10-5, 10-6, 11-6, 12-6 and maybe a few other useful sizes for 4-2-4 engines. While they may benefit from some handwork, they are not as much of a project as many Zingers. On the other hand, some sizes of Zingers are quite nicely done, such as the 11-6XW. Steve

V12 · Jun 11, 2004 10:12 AM

Hodaka#20 source
Paul - I think they also made a 250 CC dirt bike. Seems like it was called a Thunderdog or something to that effect.
What ever happened to Hodaka?
Bob Z

Steve Hulse · Jun 12, 2004 12:54 PM

#23 source
>Hodaka!! super rat, durt squirt, combat wombat, and the one
>I got stuck with, The Steen!! Gee thanks for the memos!!
>Paul

Nightflight, You left out the beautiful green Road Toad. I liked Hodak's. Lapped 'em left and right with my RM 100B back in '79-'80. Had to get past 'em quick or permanent hearing damage would set in.

Steve Hulse

KnightFlite · Jun 12, 2004 04:12 PM

#24 source
Hi steve, I finaly ended up with a 75 Kawi KX 125 back in 78. Man I had a blast on that thing, even though it was green! Very reliable and gave the Elsanores and others a run for thier money. Very good memories! Thanks-- Paul

V12 · Jun 11, 2004 10:09 AM

#19 source
Dan
Combat Wombat - there's a name I haven't heard in a while. I was in motocross and enduro for many years and the last bike I campaigned was a Wombat. It was actually the second most reliable competition bike I ever had.
The tank was chrome and the other riders called it my 2 wheeled pop-up toaster. Did quite well in the 125 CC class.
Got my parts from a place out your way - PABATCO (Pacific Bay Trading Company, as I recall).
Bob Z

dirtydan · Jun 11, 2004 03:15 PM

#21 source
>Dan
>Combat Wombat - there's a name I haven't heard in a while. I
>was in motocross and enduro for many years and the last bike
>I campaigned was a Wombat. It was actually the second most
>reliable competition bike I ever had.
>The tank was chrome and the other riders called it my 2
>wheeled pop-up toaster. Did quite well in the 125 CC class.
>Got my parts from a place out your way - PABATCO (Pacific
>Bay Trading Company, as I recall).
>Bob Z


Steve,

Looking forward to seeing you during a visit to my area. And *no* you may not "pick the spot."

Pabatco was located in Athena, Oregon. While I never actually visited, a couple of people whom were to become heavy hitters in that company--Marvin Foster and Harry Taylor--were friends of mine when still living in Yakima, Washington. Marv did a lot of free-lance photography for Pabatco, whose ad agency was located in Yakima. Thus I would get roped into riding a demo Hodaka Marv had around for the purpose, plus my 250cc Cotton, for advertising pictures, calendars, etc.

Marv was quite the eccentric, owning and letting me ride frequently, a pukka Trials bike, a DKW. This when few of us had even read of Trials competition. It was a very goofy motorcycle, even then. But it would go real slow and had lock-to-lock steering which had to be experienced to be believed. Unfortunately, it also had a serious case of head-shake, something Marv was unaware of until I just pinned it and kept shifting. I did not get spit off, the Cotton would do the same thing under precisely the right conditions, although at a much higher rate of speed.

Harry Taylor was quite the man of legend in that small town, starting out as a motorcycle mechanic. At one time he had the most bizarre trail bike, a fully tricked-out Yamaguchi 50cc piece. Most definitely *not* a mere backyard special. Harry was also a small, compact man with the strength and physic of a body builder. So where the gooch wouldn't go he would just carry it. Literally.

At that particular time I was riding a "real" trail bike, a Triumph 200cc Cub, one of the later models with bigger forks, high pipe to which Dad and I had fitted a really nice chrome reverse-cone megaphone. Anyway, all in my group had pretty decent equipment for the time, and Harry would just humiliate us in the mountains, especially when the going got really tough. We finally learned to head a different direction every time Harry would say, "Follow me, there's this great trail right over here!"

For all of you who enjoyed the various models of Hodakas over the years, Harry Taylor was the prime mover and shaker behind all of them. Even the bike they once took to Daytona. Harry even rode the thing.

As for myself, I never actually owned a Hodaka, strange as that might seem. Several years into our marriage, my wife bought a 90cc 4-speed model that was being closed out, but it was her bike and so I did not ride it much. And she didn't but rarely ride my Greeves.

Dan

Dr Spark · Jun 12, 2004 12:13 AM

#22 source
These original Y&O props bring back memories! I had a job as a high school sudent in about 1949 sanding Y&O props in my garage. I was supplied the drum sander with the air compressor to make the drum soft, and I could do many in an evening. I think Y&O gave me 5 cents for prop.. It was enough for a kid to buy balsa and supplies to keep me going. I visited Henry Orwick many times in his garage, and I used to fly with J.C. Yates at Salt Lake Park in Huntington Park, CA.

Floyd