Stuka Stunt Control Line Forum
Archive, 2000–2021 · recovered from the Internet Archive
Forums › Stuka Stunt Main Forum

America expressing thoughts

Stuka Stunt Main Forum · 19 of 19 known posts recovered

Sparky12366 · Jul 30, 2004 11:37 AM

#0 source
LAST EDITED ON Jul-30-04 AT 12:10 PM (CDT)
 
In this land of free speach Which we have the right to express. Just beacause you think diffrently than I do does that make you or I wrong? I think not.

What I precive to be true and correct is for me and maybe not for you. But if we all thought the same way we would have never gone to the moon. Everything I write here is my opinion you do with it what you want.One thing I have noticed is that the topics I write on(be it a sore spot or not) Get more play than most..

I thought this forum was for the advacement of model aircraft. You will see I never slam someone elses thoughts. I have more class than that. If it seems that I answer questions in the wrong tone thats the keyboard not me. So take it for what is worth.

ty marcucci · Jul 30, 2004 11:39 AM

RE: America#1 source
OK:P

Ty Marcucci

grzly23 · Jul 30, 2004 01:01 PM

#2 source
>In this land of free speach Which we have the right to
>express. Just beacause you think diffrently than I do does
>that make you or I wrong? I think not.
>
>What I precive to be true and correct is for me and maybe
>not for you. But if we all thought the same way we would
>have never gone to the moon. Everything I write here is my
>opinion you do with it what you want.One thing I have
>noticed is that the topics I write on(be it a sore spot or
>not) Get more play than most..
>
>I thought this forum was for the advacement of model
>aircraft. You will see I never slam someone elses thoughts.
>I have more class than that. If it seems that I answer
>questions in the wrong tone thats the keyboard not me. So
>take it for what is worth.

Mr. Spark,

Perception can be a trap. There is truth based on facts, empirical evidence and consistent results. Then there is wishful thinking. The problem is when one cannot tell the difference between truth and perception or wishful thinking. In the world that I work in that failure to know truth is called "Drinking your own bathwater." Those who avoid believing their own press releases and make the effort to stay with truth or theory based on facts, observation and empirical evidence have the fewest problems in the black and white world of aviation. Aviation, even model aviation, is very black and white, with very little gray.

Good Luck,

Tom McClain

Brett Buck · Jul 30, 2004 01:02 PM

#3 source
>In this land of free speach Which we have the right to
>express. Just beacause you think diffrently than I do does
>that make you or I wrong? I think not.

Yes. America is a grest country, in part because anyone can say anything they want, no matter how ridiculous, and the government can't stop them (ref. Democratic National Convention, Michael Moore). The same applies to responses to ridicuous statements.

Of course, this is a private forum and the proprieter can decide what to allow and what not to allow. The First Amendment does not apply to private enterprise

On objective matters, if we think differently, one of us is wrong. Not a debatable point. On a matter of opinion, we could both be right, wrong, or somewhere in between.

For instance, if you make a statement like "combat planes turn tighter because..." then that is an objective statement, and depending on the ..., can be right or wrong. It might have multiple aspects, but it's not a matter of opinion.

Alternately, if you say "I think I will score more points if I ...", then there can be differing opinions about that, legitimately. But you must base those opinions on something, and it's perfectly resonable and to be expected that if that opinion is at variance with someone else, or general wisdom, that someone may inquire as to your basis for having it.

>What I precive to be true and correct is for me and maybe
>not for you. But if we all thought the same way we would
>have never gone to the moon. Everything I write here is my
>opinion you do with it what you want.

Free expression is fine - but uni-directional declarations are really *not* what "free exchange of ideas means" I don't think anyone objects to your opinion. I for one am curious to explore your concepts. But you aren't interacting - when someone asks a question, you belittle them or make spurious references to other people. If you have an opinion, be able to explain why you hold that opinion. No one is going to pay any attention to you otherwise, aside from getting irritated.


>One thing I have
>noticed is that the topics I write on(be it a sore spot or
>not) Get more play than most..


Right, trolling can be quite effective for catching fish.

Many of the frequent posters here know more about this event in every aspect, than you do - far more. You have no detectable history in this event, and simply mouthing off and talking down to people who do will get you categorized as a net.kook very quickly. Search the archives for references to "FUBAR", "FloydC" and "PauleyP" for examples. These guys all had something useful to contribute (well, maybe not Floyd) but couldn't get past the tendency to "cover" their weak points by browbeating people and complaining about their "rights" when challenged to provide a basis, and generally conducting themselves like the output end of a horse.

You're well down that road, but not irretrievably.

Brett

Sparky12366 · Jul 30, 2004 01:08 PM

#4 source
LAST EDITED ON Jul-30-04 AT 07:29 PM (CDT)
 
I,m going to step away from the key board . I need to build instead of type. So the computer is off for now and I will return with construction upates when I have them. If I set here at this thing I like many others are getting nothing done.

Apoliges to Bret I did not fully understand what you wrote till I read it again.

By the way the experiment with the carbon fiber is lighter by 1 oz Don't know if it's a combination of wood ,glue or CF. But I stand corrected. Thanks Randy Smith..

Harleyman · Jul 30, 2004 01:36 PM

#5 source
> I Find you replies very humorous as do others.

Not I. Brett is right on the money here.

>Step away
>from the key board as I am going to. I need to build instead
>of type. So the computer is off for now and I will return
>with construction upates when I have them. If I set here at
>this thing I like many others are getting nothing done.

Interesting reply. Similar to "I can't hear you, LA LA LA LA LA LA" with fingers in ears.

Chris

tperry2054 · Jul 30, 2004 01:54 PM

#6 source
I have noticed that up to now Sparky's receive is like a deaf person with a hearing aid. He has the option of input and most of the time elects not to use it.


Tom

GLBahrman · Jul 30, 2004 02:47 PM

#7 source

> I Find you replies very humorous as do others<

Sad....Brett's post was not meant to be humorous. It was meant as constructive criticism that we all might be in tune to a communication exchange that would benefit all who are here. It wasn't even meant to degrade or harm. It was quite factual and to the point. It appears some of us are on transmit and are never on receive. That's when the communication stops. Posting here is more about sharing and being helpful to others and not so much about who's right and who's wrong.

Greg L. Bahrman

cwmcmillin · Jul 30, 2004 03:03 PM

#8 source
Save your breath Brett.
Chris...

wcrane · Jul 30, 2004 05:11 PM

#9 source
OH FOR CRYING OUT LOUD!!!

LEONARD, TURN ON THE MINUTE CHANGE FILTER NOW!!!! SOMEONE IS GETTING READY TO GO DUMP ALL HIS THREADS.

Like we haven't seen that a gillion times before.

From somewhere near Parkville, Mo.
William Crane
AMA 6733

bigseminole · Jul 30, 2004 05:44 PM

#10 source
LAST EDITED ON Jul-30-04 AT 05:59 PM (CDT)
 
Sparky, Sparky, Sparky..

Relax dude! The last time I checked, most of the guys hanging out in this place, were here to have a good time!

You might want to give some thought to the fact, that this web site is an open forum, dedicated to the idea that we have should a place at which to exchange information and ideas about our toy airplanes.

We have plenty of heated discussions and even the occasional ham-fisted argument about what we do, how things work and what it all means. That's par for the course. Most of us have learned to live with replies to our posts that range from complete acceptance and open discussion, to complete skepticism or worse.

I've noticed that far more people are interested in what you're doing and hoping to learn something from your experiments, than are trashing them.

In fact, there are several of our more learned breatheren, who appear to be bending over backwards not to take offense to your rather cranky attitude and are attempting to add their hard won experiences to your data bank.

Please... Assuming that you came here with the idea of contributing along with rest of us, drop the defensive attitude and learn to PARTICIPATE and SHARE. (Thats when information flows in both directions.) Otherwise you may find yourself in the position where no one here really cares.

Bigs

PS: If you think that I'm being unfair, please note this quote from another thread:

"I’m not trolling or trying to Sparky you..."

shelby554 · Jul 30, 2004 07:24 PM

#11 source
I'm Just gonna stay out of this, because I can't figure out what the heck we are even talking about here.

Don Jones

bigseminole · Jul 30, 2004 08:32 PM

#13 source
LOL!!!

Bigs

SoHawaii · Aug 02, 2004 02:27 PM

#15 source
I am still new here and do not know all the persons who post here. I come here to read all the opinions on any given subject so as to get a concensus as to what I want to know. If I get confused I tend to e-mail those that I need clarification from. To this date I am 100% satisfied with the differing view points available here, I agree, it's not about who's right or wrong but sharing the knowledge each holds. " There is a frustrating of plans where there is no confidential talk, but in a multitude of counselors there is accomplishment." Prov 15:7. I believe what we have here is a multitude of counselors.

SoHawaii
Ua Mau Ke Ea O Ka 'Aina I Ka Pono
("The Life/Sovereinty of the Land is Perpetuated in Righteousness")

F4FGuy · Jul 31, 2004 11:31 AM

#14 source

>In this land of free speach Which we have the right to
>express. Just beacause you think diffrently than I do does
>that make you or I wrong? I think not.

Having the right to say something does not necessarily carry with it the privelege of being the bearer of the one true word.Many on this forum would be taken a lot more seriously if they would take the time to learn to use proper spelling,grammar,and,especially,syntax.

Voltaire said"I think,therefore I am."not I speak therefore I am.".
>
>What I precive to be true and correct is for me and maybe
>not for you. But if we all thought the same way we would
>have never gone to the moon. Everything I write here is my
>opinion you do with it what you want.One thing I have
>noticed is that the topics I write on(be it a sore spot or
>not) Get more play than most..

Perceptions have little or nothing to do with truth.The farther you get from objective fact,and the closer to subjective "belief",The farther you get from science and engineering.There's nothing wrong with "out of the box" thinking,but you have to recognize it as such and do your homework,with demonstrable results,if you want it to be taken seriously.We would never have gone to the moon if every one involved worked on his own "perception" of how Space vehicles worked,and without considering ALL the facts available to him.
>
>I thought this forum was for the advacement of model
>aircraft. You will see I never slam someone elses thoughts.
>I have more class than that. If it seems that I answer
>questions in the wrong tone thats the keyboard not me. So
>take it for what is worth.

This forum IS for the advancement of model aircraft.Blaming the keyboard for your lack of understanding of basic principles is nothing short of ridiculous!READ A BOOK.An odd speculation is not a theory.A Set of odd thoughts is not a hypothesis.Hypotheses are not theories.and theories are not physical laws.

Ron B.
F4Fguy

Ion Muniz · Aug 02, 2004 03:36 PM

#16 source
Voltaire said"I think,therefore I am

You mean René Decartes...

Ion

F4FGuy · Aug 03, 2004 12:59 AM

#17 source
Ron B.
F4Fguy

Sorry,Ion,I got my french philosophers mixed up. You are,of course,correct.

Ron B.

Bill Groman · Aug 03, 2004 08:18 AM

#18 source
LAST EDITED ON Aug-03-04 AT 08:19 AM (CDT)
 
>Voltaire said"I think,therefore I am
>
>You mean René Decartes...
>
>Ion

You mean Descartes...

Bill Groman

"There is no such thing as the wrong way to enjoy a hobby"

Warhawk · Aug 04, 2004 08:51 AM

#19 source
"There is no such thing as the wrong way to enjoy a hobby"

Aren't Golf, Sex, and Model Airplanes three things that you don't have to be good at to enjoy?


Warhawk