>Doug,
>
>According to the IRS's own publications (certainly suspect),
>middle income (the de facto middle class) is anyone making
>from $28,000 (the default "poverty line") and
>$135,000 a year. This currently constitutes approximately 44%
>of the total incomes in the United States (as a percentage of
>households filing). They provide approximately 78% of the
>total taxes collected in any given tax year. According to
>research by University of Washington, the total is closer to
>82%, but that's a quibble. Again, according to the IRS, the
>average (mean) middle class American pays approximately 46% of
>their total income to taxes in a given year (granted, that
>includes all taxes including income tax, sales tax, excise tax
>and a multitudinous host of other taxes). The average for
>people (families) making more than $145,000 a year is harder
>to determine (again, according to the IRS) it is believed that
>at least some of the income earned and expended is done in
>other countries (and hidden) or "under the table"
>and so is not counted. But the average tax paid (again, all
>taxes), based on figures they have is 19 to 26%. Tough to tell
>how much of that is income tax (the publication I read didn’t
>distinguish for income over 145,000), but in any case it’s
>probably a larger proportion individually than what the middle
>class pays.
Those numbers seem very skewed to me. Having family members in and over the ranges you talk about they dont make sense. From a purely income tax stand point. I am talking purely IRS income tax. Not state income tax and or other taxes. 19-26% that is way too low from what I have been told by people in those brackets. But I am not in the higher bracket so I cant tell you for sure.
>
> When you have enough money,
And just who determines what enough money is. My next door neighbor, at my old house, earned about 3/4 what I was earning when we lived there. He had 3 kids and his wife didnt work. I had one kid and my wife was working. He spent his money properly and therefore he had enough. I didnt and therefore I didnt have enough.
Having enough money is based on the decisions we make in our daily lives. Not some arbitrary number the govt hands out as a threshold. That is why it is not fair to say "You make more so your % is higher than that group over there. We are equal and should be taxed equal % across the board. Whether you make $10 a year or $10,000,000 a year. The % should always be the same.
That was several years ago. I am now a loan officer for a National mortgage company. I talk to people every day about getting loans. Second loans in particular. It is common for me to have to tell people who make 15-25K per month that they have too much debt to income ratio for them to qualify for a second loan on their house. Hoe much is enough, and who determines?
Sorry to rant. Off to play poker.
